In the Dark Star Perry Mattfeld and Mark Sanchez Are Engaged  —  See the Stunning Photos!
The former NFL quarterback, 35, popped the question to the In the Dark star, 28, earlier this week while the pair were vacationing on an island in the Eastern Caribbean. "The proposal happened at sunset on Monday, May 9, at the Belmond Cap Juluca on the beautiful island of Anguilla," Mattfeld tells PEOPLE. RELATED: Here's What Mark Sanchez Has to Say About QBs Like Pat Mahomes, Aaron Rodgers and Dak Prescott "Mark personalized everything. From our initials he put in my ring, to the songs he picked for our private concert," she continues. "He picked the menu for our intimate dinner, paired with my favorite wine, and he had my parents appear out of nowhere! I was so surprised and emotional.